On the Brink of Jazz

New Orleans has always marched to the beat of its own drum – literally – and the world has been listening for almost two centuries. Long before cities like New York and Chicago could claim the spotlight, New Orleans stood as America's original music capital. But what did the Crescent City sound like in the late 19th century, when this production of Pirates! is set, just before jazz bursts onto the scene? On a warm, muggy evening in the 1880s, the streets would have been alive with the brassy blast of a marching band, the distant strains of a string ensemble drifting from a dance hall, and a lively mix of rhythms pouring out of Congo Square. The night air would have been thick with music, each sound mixing with the next, creating a symphony of cultures and traditions. This was the music that shaped a city on the verge of a musical revolution, a city that was already an incubator for what would soon be known as jazz. 

A Cultural Melting Pot with a Sound All Its Own

New Orleans was – and still is – a crossroads of cultures. By the 19th century, the city's diverse population included people of African descent, Creoles, Europeans, and Caribbean immigrants, each contributing to its rich musical landscape. The arrival of free Black West Indians in the early 1800s further enriched this cultural exchange, as they brought with them European musical training and a deep appreciation for rhythm and melody. These musicians introduced new techniques and traditions, which quickly merged with existing local sounds. As Curtis D. Jerde writes in Black Music in New Orleans: A Historical Overview: 

The arrival of a West Indian contingent of Blacks in the early nineteenth century bolstered New Orleans's complement of free Blacks in particular. Predicated upon the social advantages they enjoyed, this group brought with them a wealth of educational and cultural richness which manifested itself in much musical facility. Like an analogous component of Afro-American society then already present in New Orleans, they had ready access to European musical training. 

This unique blend of influences set the stage for the development of a musical identity unlike any in the country. Every corner of the city pulsed with the energy of musical exchange, from French-style opera houses to back-alley juke joints where raw, passionate sounds were being born. 

But the cultural intermingling didn't stop there. New Orleans' status as a major port city meant that sailors, traders, and travelers from around the world introduced new instruments, musical techniques, and performance traditions. The Creole community played perhaps the most crucial role in preserving and innovating musical styles, blending European classical training with African rhythms to create something entirely new. In doing so, they bridged the gap between formal musical education and oral traditions, ensuring that their influence would resonate for generations to come. This synthesis of styles laid the foundation for jazz, giving it a uniquely New Orleans character that set it apart from other genres. 

Where Music Lived: The Halls, the Streets, & the Square

Music wasn't confined to parlors or concert halls in 19th-century New Orleans – it was everywhere. Congo Square became the outdoor hub for both free and enslaved Black musicians, where the sounds of African drumming and call-and-response singing filled the air. Meanwhile, dance halls like the Masonic Temple and Eureka Hall hosted raucous performances that blurred the line between classical and folk traditions. These venues were not merely spaces for entertainment; they were communal gathering spots where people of all backgrounds came together to celebrate, mourn, and connect through music. From grand ballrooms to the sidewalks of the French Quarter, New Orleans was a city in constant musical motion, where improvisation and innovation flourished. 

One unique feature of New Orleans' musical culture was the city's penchant for parades. Brass bands would march through neighborhoods, providing the soundtrack for everything from funerals to political rallies. The tradition of the "second line," where revelers would follow behind musicians, dancing and celebrating, became an essential part of the city's identity. These street performances weren't just entertainment – they were a form of communal storytelling, a way for people to express joy, sorrow, and resilience through music. They also served as impromptu classrooms, where younger musicians learned by playing alongside their elders, absorbing the intricacies of the rhythms and melodies that would define their careers. 

The Sounds of the City: Brass, Strings, & Caribbean Rhythms

Before jazz, the city's soundtrack was a patchwork of musical styles. Horn groups like the Excelsior and Onward Brass Bands provided the powerful pulse of public celebrations. Meanwhile, string bands filled dance floors with quadrilles and polkas, their melodies deeply intertwined with Creole and Caribbean traditions. The energy in these performances was electric, with musicians constantly pushing boundaries and experimenting with new sounds. 

One of the most striking influences on New Orleans music came from the Caribbean. The Crescent City's proximity to the islands meant that musicians moved freely between the regions, and this musical cross-pollination was unmistakable in the rhythms of early jazz and rhythm & blues. Jerde offers: 

The Caribbean connection represents as especially vital linkage for Black musical development in New Orleans. By the second decade of the nineteenth century, the arrival of a substantial number of West Indians, both slave and free, had mushroomed the Black population in the Crescent City substantially. Situated as it is on the northern rim, New Orleans actually counts as a Caribbean community, and the transit of musicians back and forth has left a considerable impression upon the city's vernacular musical style. Both the jazz and rhythm & blues traditions endemic to the city convey rhythmic elements suggestive of West Indian influence. 

Even Mexican military bands left their mark, introducing brass-driven harmonies that local musicians adapted into their own vibrant style. These influences coalesced in the city's musical underground, where improvisation and collaboration were the norm rather than the exception. The creative energy in New Orleans was unlike anything seen elsewhere in America, and it was this dynamic musical ecosystem that allowed jazz to take root and flourish. 

The Instruments That Shaped a Genre

Nearly every instrument had some role in crafting New Orleans' pre-jazz sound. Brass instruments – trumpets, trombones, and tubas – took center stage in parades and street performances. One early pioneer, Papa Celestin, led a brass band – the Original Tuxedo Orchestra – that helped define the New Orleans sound in the early 20th century and is generally accepted as one of the very first to deliver jazz to a wide audience outside of the city. String instruments also played a crucial role, with violins, banjos, and guitars setting the rhythm for dance music and Creole folk tunes. 

Pianos also became an essential part of the city's musical fabric. The emergence of ragtime, a precursor to jazz, was driven by syncopated rhythms played on the piano. This style was popularized by musicians like Tony Jackson, who honed his craft in the saloons and brothels of New Orleans' red-light district, Storyville. The fusion of bluesy improvisation and structured European harmonies on the piano foreshadowed the evolution of jazz as a distinct genre. 

The Evolution Toward Jazz

As 19th-century New Orleans music continued to evolve, it became a fusion of African rhythms and European harmonies – an unmistakable precursor to jazz. Virtuoso composer Louis Moreau Gottschalk was one of the first to blend African and European elements in his piano compositions, foreshadowing the improvisational spirit that would define jazz. 

Music has long been a form of cultural expression and communal identity for New Orleans' Black communities in particular. Whether in the lively gospel choirs or the syncopated swing of the music that was becoming jazz, every note carries a story, a struggle, and a triumph. It's no wonder the city's soundscape is as rich and resilient as the people who created it – because here, music isn't just heard; it's lived. 

This deep connection between music and identity set the stage for the rich cross-cultural exchanges that were shaping jazz's early evolution. People from different backgrounds were coming together in shared public spaces like the outdoor Congo Square to create music; the combination of styles was what defined jazz. And no one embodied this fusion more than Jelly Roll Morton, the self-proclaimed "originator of jazz." Born in 1890, Morton's Creole heritage and exposure to Caribbean rhythms made him a pioneer in arranging the new sounds of New Orleans into the emerging genre of jazz. 

Despite a commonly repeated myth, segregation laws didn't force musicians together – quite the opposite, in fact. Both Jelly Roll Morton and Louis Armstrong claim to have fled New Orleans in part because increasing segregation was hurting the music scene. According to Jerah Johnson, it was the deteriorating economic conditions across all races and cultures in 1890s New Orleans that led all lower-class workers to suffer together – and play music together. He writes: 

It is true that, by the 1890s, Blacks were experiencing a squeeze in the job market, but that had nothing to do with the Jim Crow laws, for it affected all working classes of New Orleans, black and white. The squeeze resulted far more from economic than from racial factors. In the 1880s and 1890s a huge influx of Italian immigrants settled in New Orleans and began competing with native New Orleanians, black and white, for unskilled work. At the same time, industrial machinery was displacing many skilled workers and artisans, cigar rollers and tin- smiths, for example. And labour unions were organizing craftsmen, particularly masons, plasterers and carpenters, long the strongholds of Franco-African artisans. 

Segregation could not bring about jazz, Johnson argues, because "Jazz is a music of urban civilization and complexity, not a music of cultural isolation or of racial singularity." 

A Lasting Influence

Ironically, as jazz took the world by storm in the 20th century, its popularity in New Orleans began to wane. Modernization, shifting social dynamics, and a general increase in segregation led to a decline in the local jazz scene. It was tourism that breathed new life into the genre, turning it into a cultural touchstone for visitors eager to experience the city's musical legacy. Jazz clubs and festivals began to proliferate, preserving the city's connection to its musical roots while simultaneously propelling the genre forward. This revival paralleled – and may be attributed to – the preservation of the French Quarter, proving that while jazz may have evolved, its roots in New Orleans remain strong. 

The vibrant rhythms of Congo Square and the bold brass of parade bands continue to resonate through American music, leaving an indelible mark far beyond the streets of 19th-century New Orleans. We hear the sound in Harry Connick Jr.'s vocal stylings and orchestrations, in Dr. John's funk arrangements and ceremonious stage declarations, and in the Neville Brothers' soul-infused four-part harmonies. From jazz and blues to rock and beyond, the city's musical legacy has shaped generations, securing its place as a powerhouse of innovation and influence. So, whether it's a soaring trumpet or a syncopated beat, chances are you're hearing the unmistakable spirit of New Orleans alive in every note, a testament to the city's enduring love affair with music. 

SOURCES